Sportsmanship means to be fair in following the rules of the game. If one loses, one congratulates the winning team and does not begrudge them the win. If one wins, one commends the losing team on their valiant effort in trying to win. To be a sportsman does not mean just to be proficient in a certain sport. It also means understanding and displaying the underlying moral values of sports that should be inculcated into all who truly respect the sport. Sportsmen want to win, but they do not result to unscrupulous means to do so. I think this is the true beauty of sports: the human element.
I think, in the above scenario, the act of cheating definitely was not justified. The match was being held in Bukit Jalil National Stadium, in Kuala Lumpur. The Malaysians already had the advantage of home ground. Of course, the normal exchange of jaunts and attempts at intimidating the opposing team was inevitable. It is a commonplace occurence at soccer matches all around the world, especially one as important as the qualifiers for the World Cup. However, I think the Malaysians definitely did not need to stoop as low as attempting to sabotage the Singapore team's defense, throwing bottles at the Singaporean fans with intention of bodily harm or taunting the Singaporeans by calling them dogs. I feel the Malaysians should be more accepting of the loss, which resulted from completely clean play on the Singaporean side and an arsenal of underhand tricks from the Malaysian side. I am not just speaking in my capacity as a Singaporean. While I am enraged by the fact that Malaysia, which has fostered close relations with Singapore over the half century we have been independent, I am looking at the situation as an observer. If the Malaysian team really wanted to win that badly, there were many alternatives to cheating. They could have trained harder, recruited better players and studied the weaknesses of the Singaporean team more. The fact that they tried to take the easy way out shows that they were just too lazy to put in more effort and thusly do not deserve the win.
However, I do not think it is right to fight fire with fire. The Malaysian team may have been less than accepting of the win on the Singaporean side and insulted Singapore by saying it is "nothing without foreign players". The Malaysian fans were extremely unhappy about the loss. The Singaporean fans may have been attacked. Does that give Singaporeans the right to stoop to their level and retaliate? I do not think so. Just because someone may have been wronged, does it mean that he is justified to take the law into his own hands and retaliate? No. The Singaporean who hacked into the Malaysian football website is not only showing that he is incapable of ignoring meaningless insults, he is also damaging relations between Singapore and Malaysia even further. If nobody on the Singaporean side had retaliated, Singapore would have been completely justified in accusing Malaysia of being the agressor. Now the matter has been complicated as Malaysia now has a counter-argument to Singapore's accusations. Instead of being resolved in a relatively short period of time, the matter is likely to drag on longer.
To end off, here is an edited quote from Shakespeare in his play, The Merchant of Venice.
"The quality of sportsmanship is not strained; it droppeth as the gentle rain from heaven upon the place beneath. It is twice blest; it blesseth him that gives and him that takes." So may you be also a sportsman, and not only enjoy sports more, but allow others to enjoy it more as well.
Dear Daniel,
ReplyDeleteYes, I have been reading the newspapers and am truly disturbed by this matter which has made it to one of the most read news.
I would also like to note here that the Malaysian supporters later vandalised the Singapore flag with jeering words that the team was full of "losers" (with the word being spelt wrongly anyway). This totally exhibits an acute sense of immaturity on the side of the Malaysians.
However, the Singaporeans "followed the Malaysian example, but better exacted the punishment" (another edited quote from Shakespeare in his play, The Merchant of Venice). They went on an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth.
This only serves to aggravate the already strained diplomatic relations between Singapore and Malaysia. The Malaysian Cup has just recently begun, and Singapore has been given the opportunity to compete.
However, I think this will only serve to worsen the relationship between the two nations! As can be seen, the Malaysians are fierce supporters and Singaporeans are too. Every game which ends up in a win-loss situation will probably take the supporters to the streets - burning cars, fighting, screaming, shouting... I guess, draw situations will also cause the same aftermath.
Thus, I really suggest that Singapore pull out of the Malaysian Cup. I'd rather we be treated as wimps and not participate, than cause riots and strained relations with Malaysia.
Regards,
Nathan (:
I do not think the radical measure of pulling out of the Malaysian Cup is necessary. There are other solutions as well. We can explore alternatives, such as government reminders to the public that sportsmanship is more important than the result of the game. While I agree it is better than causing strained relations, is it not possible to try other means first?
ReplyDeleteI acknowledge your comment, that the Malaysian supporters also vandalised the Singapore flag with the derogatory comment of "loser". (which was incorrectly spelt) The Singapore flag is our sign of unity, our symbol of pride, our testament to the trials of time. Not only are the Malaysian fans insulting the Singapore soccer team and the Singapore soccer fans, they are also insulting Singapore as a whole.
I hope we can try other measures first. It would be a bad sign of how poor our relations with Malaysia have become if some discontentment over the results of a soccer game can disrupt diplomatic relations.
Regards,
Daniel Tan Chee Hian
2i107
Hi Daniel,
ReplyDeleteI agree with your viewpoint, whereby we should not fight fire with fire by also hacking into Malaysi's websites. By doing so, it only asks for even more of such actions again as violence only begets violence. It could also potentially lead to the worsening of the relationships of both countries as the citizens of both country do not get together.
This is when sportsmanship comes in. If only the Malaysian supporters has sportsmanship, then all of these would not have had happened and would then no threathn to affect the close relationship of both countries.
All these then thus show the importance of sportsmanship, because without it, there would be no peace in the sports.
Regards,
Gordon